Mike Silva's New York Baseball Digest » Blog Archive » With Recent Acquisitions, Yanks Need to Rid Themselves of Burnett

With Recent Acquisitions, Yanks Need to Rid Themselves of Burnett

By Joseph Delgrippo ~ January 21st, 2012. Filed under: Digest Contributors, New York Yankees.

Since Brian Cashman traded Jesus Montero for RHP Michael Pineda, and then signed RHP Hiroki Kuroda to a one-year deal for $10 million, the Yankees are flush with starting pitchers. It appears that in all the frenzied moments of last Friday, the Yankees lost track of how many major league ready starting pitchers they really had in their organization. For purposes of this article, they have eight who have pitched in the major leagues plus three others on the precipice, who I believe are ready for the major leagues.

The starting rotation appears to be some combination of CC Sabathia, Ivan Nova, Hiroki Kuroda and Michael Pineda, with Freddy Garcia, Phil Hughes and A.J. Burnett battling for the final spot. Dellin Betances also has a few major league innings under his belt, but should pitch most of the 2012 season at Triple-A Rochester.

The old, but relatively new, adage is you can’t have enough pitching, especially quality starting pitching. With injuries invariably occurring within most starting rotations, smart organizations will have an additional veteran or several ready youngsters to fill in starts where needed.

See also: 2011 Boston Red Sox.

But even after these two starting rotation moves, if I told you the Yankees can get another veteran starting pitcher for their rotation, who, during various seasons, led his league in games started, strikeouts, lowest hits per nine innings and fewest home runs per nine innings, would you be interested?

And the guy is only looking for a two-year deal for a little over $15 million per, just enough time for Manny Banuelos to get a little more seasoning in Triple-A before he takes a spot in the rotation. And this veteran wouldn’t cost the Yankees a draft pick or any prospects.

Wouldn’t this be a good pickup? Don’t you want him? He would really round out that new rotation, wouldn’t he?

But the Yankees currently have three veteran arms vying for that fifth spot. Garcia threw very well last season (ERA+ of 122) in the difficult-to-navigate lineups of the AL East. Hughes threw the ball much better late last season, showing glimpses of his 2010 performance. However, many people believe Burnett, because he is being paid $16.5 million this season (and next), is a lock to get that final spot.

Most Yankee fans dislike Burnett, and I had previously written that the Yankees shouldn’t even have signed him.

If you had the opportunity, would you sign Burnett again if he were a free agent? Of course not. Not even for two years at a total of $33 million, that same amount the Yankees still owe him? Nope.

Yet, that veteran pitcher I previously mentioned for a two-year deal is A.J. Burnett. He did lead his league at one time in all of those categories.

Since he is getting paid very well, some people feel AJ should get that fifth spot, and somehow will make him a better pitcher.

The current theory is that since Burnett is getting all that loot, there is no reason to “waste” that money by shipping him to the bullpen to throw maybe twice every week. I disagree. A thought is that his win total likely would look better if facing the other teams’ fifth starter most of the time.

My win total would be better facing a fifth starter more often, too.

But there are several reasons why Burnett should NOT be considered for the Yankee rotation and, in fact, should not even be on their roster come opening day.

First, Burnett is not a good pitcher. Not even close. Many people say “he has great stuff.” A.J. does NOT have great stuff. Great stuff does not get you a 34-35 record in three seasons as a Yankee, especially with this offense, and ERAs over 5.00 each of the last two seasons. Great stuff doesn’t allow you to allow the most walks (2009), most hit batters (2010), most wild pitches (2009 & 2011) in the league while also allowing 81 home runs during these three seasons.

Second, A.J. has mostly been a malcontent. When things didn’t go his way in Florida late in 2005, he lashed out against the team and was suspended for the balance of the season. During his Yankee tenure, Burnett appeared with a black eye, which no one in the organization talked about. Do you really think that if his role with the Yankees was reduced, he would abide by Joe Girardi’s decisions regarding his reduced playing time?

And forget about Burnett to the bullpen. The Yankees already have Mariano, Robertson and Soriano, with Joba coming back mid-year. They don’t need Burnett stirring up garbage down there.

Third, A.J. will not improve his performance. He is what he is, a mediocre pitcher who USED to have the best fastball in baseball. He also has a good curve ball, which he cannot control and rarely throws consistent strikes with the pitch. He has no command over either pitch, and that costs him dearly. Like 81 HRs dear over the last three seasons. As I said last off season, new pitching coach Larry Rothschild would not be able to “fix” Burnett.

Even though Burnett did stop lots of his movement during his delivery, it still did not help his command. How many times have you seen the Yankee catcher set up outside and A.J.’s pitch is delivered up and in or, even worse, down the middle, and it gets whacked pretty hard?

Too many times to count.

Fourth, A.J. is getting worse. He was terrible the second half of last season, getting bombed in most of his starts. His slash line allowed was .316/.387/.554/.942 OPS with a 6.85 ERA and 1.746 WHIP. All that with a K/9 rate of 9.3. So much for a pitchers ability to get strikeouts.

In Burnett’s 13 year career, he has had eight full seasons with minimum of 25 starts. His two worst seasons of those eight? Yep, his last two seasons, all in Yankee pinstripes. And his 2009 season wasn’t all that great, either.

What makes you think AJ will suddenly turn it around? His glowing personality? The way he glares at Kim Jones after a biting question after another bad start?

If A.J. was in the starting rotation, the Yankees would get a .500 or worse pitcher who loses concentration on the mound, and cracks under pressure.

Fifth, the Yankees are paying Phil Hughes $3.2 million this season. The Yankees are not paying Hughes that much money to pitch in the bullpen…at least not during the first half of the season. Hughes has been the Yankee golden child since being drafted in 2004, and the Yankees want to see how he looks as a starter this season before deciding whether he will become another bullpen arm, especially after his improved performance late last season. I just wish Hughes would stop throwing that cutter, as I feel it’s a velocity reducer.

Sixth, Freddy Garcia is a better pitcher, with better stuff than Burnett, and is currently signed for 2011. In 2010, Garcia had a better season than Burnett and appears to be a better teammate. Garcia took Nova under his wing last year and was a guiding force in Nova’s development. Don’t think for a second that Garcia will not be as equally valuable to the recently acquired Pineda. Unless Garcia gives them permission (a possibility now), the Yankee cannot trade Garcia until at least June. I hope they keep him around.

Let’s say Burnett repeats what he averaged over the last three seasons. That would be a sub .500 record, ERA of 4.79, BB/9 rate of 4.0, HR/9 rate of 1.2 with a WHIP of 1.447. Those are the numbers of a kid prospect usually puts up his rookie season. Hell, Zach Britton of the Baltimore Orioles had a better season than Burnett last year. Would you rather have a kid prospect putting up those numbers or A.J. Burnett? I even feel that as a fifth starter, A.J.’s attitude would worsen and his actual numbers would not even be that good.

So why not have David Phelps or Adam Warren, two pitchers who I feel are major league ready get those necessary starts? I have confidence both guys could at least replicate, or likely better, Burnett’s numbers from the last two seasons. In his most recent chat (1/19/12), ESPN’s Keith Law said he feels both Phelps and Warren are “major league ready, back end starters.”

I agree, and the Yankee would be better off with one of them in the rotation rather than AJ Burnett.

With a plethora of major league ready pitchers plus two (if not three or four) major league ready prospect starters in the minors, there is no room for Burnett on the staff, either in the rotation or the bullpen.

That means he should not even be on the roster.

But no one wants to trade for Burnett. The Yankees found that out when they shopped him over the last couple months. But those trade proposals had the Yankees paying about half of Burnett’s salary for the next two seasons. No team in its right mind would trade for Burnett and pay $16 million to him.

Well, maybe Kenny Williams of the Chicago White Sox would, as he did for Alex Rios and Jake Peavy. Maybe Williams would trade Gordon Beckham for Burnett.

Seriously, though, the prior trade proposals did not match what the trend is for other veteran, high-price pitchers. That is for the current team to pay MOST of the salary, like the Chicago Cubs did with Carlos Zambrano to the Miami Marlins, and Atlanta Braves did with trading Derek Lowe to the Cleveland Indians. The Yankees should be willing to pay $30 million of the current $33 million Burnett is currently owed. That would then interest a few teams.

That is money wasted, but what good is it having Burnett pitch due to his salary, if he continues to pitch very badly? That is like a stock trader throwing good money after bad money when the bad stock goes down in value. Burnett’s salary is already a sunk cost. No reason to hurt the Yankees in 2012 by pitching Burnett, especially with good team like the Tampa Bay Rays, Boston Red Sox, Los Angeles Angels, Texas Rangers and maybe the Toronto Blue Jays fighting the Yankees for the precious few playoff spots.

If the Yankees pay most of Burnett’s salary, certain teams like the San Francisco Giants, Oakland A’s, and Detroit Tigers might be tempted; all teams who pitch in big parks, which Burnett might benefit. But a team like the Kansas City Royals with all their kids, they might need a veteran to allow the kids like Mike Montgomery and to develop a little more.

As told to the Kansas City Star’s Bob Dutton, Royals general manager Dayton Moore said “We’re not done. We’re still looking to add another pitcher.”

No matter what team would want Burnett, it is imperative for the Yankees to rid themselves of a guy who really isn’t any good. If no trades can be made, I would vote for an outright release. There are much better opportunities for the Yankees rotation and bullpen now and in the future.

Joseph Delgrippo is an aspiring sportswriter and TV baseball analyst. He played NCAA baseball, at tiny Marietta (OH) College, participating in the Division 3 World Series. In addition, he's coached baseball at the high school level. His knowledge of this game goes far beyond what is shown on television.
Joseph Delgrippo
View all posts by Joseph Delgrippo
Josephs website

Post to Twitter Post to Yahoo Buzz Post to Delicious Post to Digg Post to Facebook

7 Responses to With Recent Acquisitions, Yanks Need to Rid Themselves of Burnett

  1. Tanned Tom

    I agree, they should trade this clown whatever the cost. Make Garcia the 5th starter and Hughes the spot starter/long reliever. I fear Cashman will try to hoard starters as insurance against injuries, or to see if the price on Burnett will improve. But I favor making that deal now. If it takes paying over $25 mil, so be it, the money’s spent anyway.
    The next decision though, is on Hughes. He’s worn out his welcome by showing up out of shape, but might have some decent trade value near the end of spring training or even at the trading deadline. I’m for trading fat boy too. Let Warren or Phelps, or anyone who takes their job seriously, have that roster spot.

  2. Joseph DelGrippo

    Clown is a very apt term for Burnett. Wish I thought of it.

    Apparently, Hughes has been diligently working out at the API Complex in Los Angeles, the same place he worked out before the 2010 season.

    The Yankees will give Hughes a shot to start (Garcia being swing man), and if Hughes struggles early, the switch will be made and Phil would become another back end bullpen guy.

    Many people in the organization feel that Hughes might be the future closer, but they will give him time to show he belongs in the rotation.

    In the next couple of years, the Yankees have a lot of decisions to be made in the bullpen. Hughes, Joba and Soriano are all free agents after 2013 and Robertson is a FA after 2014.

    And by that time, Mariano might even be gone.

  3. Ken

    I agree completely.

    Whenever I read about AJ’s “terrific stuff”, I just shake my head; the only thing that counts is his ERA and to some extent, his other stats.

    He is simply a burden to the Yankees and now that he knows that the Yankees were (are…) trying their best to get rid of him, it can only get worse.

    Better to have some combination of young pitchers take all of AJ’s starts in 2012. At least that will give them real Major League experience.

  4. Ron

    Cashman will never release AJ. He will lose face with ownership. A good trade for both sides would be AJ and Swisher to the Indians for Grady Sizemore and Fausto Carmona. The Indians desperately want Swisher. So they can have him if they take AJ. Meanwhile, the Yanks are assume risk also, since Sizemore is coming off of a bad injury and Carmona has an identity problem. If Sizemore resorts back to his old form, he is better than Swisher, plus he will be two years removed from his injury. Assuming Carmona can resolve his identity problems, a reunion with CC may bring him back to his Cy Young form.

  5. Chuck Johnson

    Look, while the chances are slim the Yanks would flat release Burnett are slim, Joe does make a good point here.

    For starters, he has a limited, adjustable no-trade clause in his contract. He can block trades to ten teams per year, and can edit those teams annually, as long as he turns in his list before opening day.

    So, right there you’re eliminating 30% of the league as potential trade partners.

    If you release him, you eliminate that problem.

    Then you have to take into consideration his money.

    How much would the Yanks be willing to eat?

    Keeping in mind the less they take on, the less the return.

    If the Yanks take on 60% of his money, they might get back a utility guy or a couple of B level prospects, but in reality the return is irrelevant, because you’re not trading the player, you’re trading the contract.

    Toronto didn’t trade Vernon Wells, they traded his money. They could have gotten a half dozen season passes to Disneyland and it would have been a good deal.

    But, if the Yanks release Burnett, and he signs with someone else, they are only on the hook for the difference in the two contracts.

    Let’s say he signs a two year, 24 million deal with the White Sox.

    The Yanks owe Burnett $4.5 per year.

    They could also come to some kind of buy-out agreement, where the Yanks could write him a $20 million check and that would be that.

  6. Joseph DelGrippo

    “A good trade for both sides would be AJ and Swisher to the Indians for Grady Sizemore and Fausto Carmona.”

    I would trade Burnett straight up for both those guys, then release or trade Carmona right away (he sucks), and hope Sizemore stays on the field for more than a week at a time.

    So, when Sizemore gets hurt AGAIN, what do the Yankees do for a starting outfielder? Can’t trade Swisher without getting a sure thing to replace him, and Sizemore is the furthest OF from a sure thing.

    Sorry, no. Best bet is to release Burnett before spring training, and when a team signs AJ, the team saves a million bucks.

  7. Mister D

    The money is gone. The roster spot matters more at this point. Eat whatever they have to. I say this even though I like Burnett and I think he’s been a decent teammate. The point is his future is limited, and it is better for the Yankees to put a kid in that spot, because they really couldn’t be worse.

Leave a Reply