What’s Behind A-Rod’s Postseason Turnaround?
By Mike Silva ~ October 13th, 2009. Filed under: 2009 Playoffs, Mike Silva.
I discussed this on Sunday and once again was criticized for saying that a “relaxed” A-Rod has as much to do with his success than anything. Dr. John F Murray, who appeared on my show back in June, had the following to say in Sunday’s New York Post.
“If he’s becoming a little more honest . . . he would have less anxiety,” said Palm Beach sports psychologist Dr. John Murray. “He would sleep better at night and be more relaxed. More focused. That is key.”
Dr. Murray was responding to a quote from a team insider who said A-Rod has “ditched his philandering ways and is making a big effort to inject honesty and openness into his relationship with the actress Kate Hudson.” If only he had met Hudson five years ago perhaps the Yankees would already have their 27th World Series. I am kidding of course, but you have to admit that there is a clear change in A-Rod at the plate. That is why anyone who cites “small sample size” is not looking at the big picture.
Ken Davidoff, who embraces all sorts of modern statistical theory, echoed much of what I have been saying on the show and the blog:
It’s never as simple as “Now A-Rod is relaxed, therefore, now he’s great.” Someone has to pitch the ball to him, after all, and that pitch might be sublime, horrible or somewhere in between. But my goodness, he’s playing the game with such a peace now, if you will. In previous postseasons, in tight spots or with runners on base, you could feel the tension oozing from his body. Yes, sometimes such tension can produce a flare, broken-bat single, and results are all that matter. But I can’t remember too many instances in the previous five years where the defense robbed A-Rod of a hit. He just didn’t square up the ball too often.
I have seen most every inning of Yankees postseason baseball the last 10 years. The pressure clearly got to A-Rod, along with many others on the Yankees, during the 2004 ALCS. Davidoff said it best when citing the lack of hard hit balls throughout the postseason. I wish I could get a copy of the ESPN interview before the 06′ Detroit series. A-Rod was so tight during the conversation I thought he was going to snap like a rubber band. Obviously none of us are in A-Rod’s head, but it doesn’t take a PhD in psychology to recognize bad body language when you see it.
Finally, I think you have to point out how Rodriguez has made peace with Derek Jeter. The one black mark on Jeter’s captain legacy is how he handled A-Rod’s transition to New York and the Yankees. NYBD contributor Frank Russo mentioned in his Monday column that A-Rod, “stressed by the spotlight of both the Selena Roberts steroid story and his hip surgery, had a heartfelt talk with Jeter sometime during the season, where he “again” apologized for the comments he made about him in the April 2001 issue of Esquire Magazine.” I think it was petty of Jeter, and showed that even the great one can fall to one of the seven deadly sins, but at least A-Rod finally owned up and helped put the situation behind the duo. Peer pressure and respect is a big thing in sports. Sometimes confidence can be something as simple as the support of your teammates. Of course, you can’t discount good pitching, fielding, and hitting, however the difference between playoff teams is so minuscule that the “intangibles” often can put a team over the top.
A-Rod is not out of the woods as Anaheim comes to town on Friday. Something tells me that his performance against the Twins was no accident and we will see more of this as the Yanks attempt to win title number 27.
If you missed NYBD contributor Frank Russo and I wrap up the ALDS and talk about A-Rod, as well as other Yankees topics, click here to download the replay.
October 13th, 2009 at 6:25 am
Mike -
Sorry I missed the show last night …I saw Murray’s post and
was nodding along, albeit for my own reasons. When you combine A-Rod’s outer performance and his renewed inner perspective, especially in the ‘late & close’ spots in the post-season, all I see is a coherent PHYLO doing his job…well.
A-Rod, like all PHYLO’s, is wired to have superior gross motor skills. So if he’s reduced his distractions, and in the process gained more intimacy and interpersonal clarity (read: honesty, resolution with The Captain…) he’s shifted from being a defensive fine motor ‘swinger’ to the natural, effortless ‘slugger’ he is. If anyone saw Ryan Howard’s swings in Game 3 and 4, that’s pure PHYLO, locked in despite the situation. Contrast that to the LOCO
(low coherence) breakdowns of a fine motor wired ONTO reliever like Papelbon or poor PHYLO Matt Holliday last THURS…
That said, let’s go Angels! MRF 10.13
http://www.somaspace.org/phyloscript.html
http://www.somaspace.org/ontoscript.html
October 13th, 2009 at 10:16 am
The pressure clearly got to A-Rod, along with many others on the Yankees, during the 2004 ALCS
A-Rod – 2004 ALCS .258/.378/.516/.895 2 HR
That’s GOLD, Jerry!
October 13th, 2009 at 12:56 pm
Arod’s career postseason line: 290/379/503
Jeter’s career postseason line: 311/381/477
They’re essentially identical.
October 13th, 2009 at 1:41 pm
“A-Rod is not out of the woods as Anaheim comes to town on Friday. Something tells me that his performance against the Twins was no accident and we will see more of this as the Yanks attempt to win title number 27.”
What does this mean, Mike? Are you reserving the right to re-attach the choker label? Or claim that he is back to being a Nervous Nellie? Or that Jeter is again shunning him?
October 13th, 2009 at 1:55 pm
I think he wont shed the choker label with just 3 good games. He needs to perform against Anaheim. It’s more about how he performs and less about the team. If A-Rod hits the cover off the ball, but as SF lost to Anaheim in 02′, the Yanks lose the same way, how can you blame him?
Ironically I thought the Yanks could survive a cold A-Rod because of their lineup, but without him, we might be preparing for Minny/Anaheim
October 13th, 2009 at 2:34 pm
“I think he wont shed the choker label with just 3 good games”
What if his career postseason line is just as good as Jeter’s? Shouldn’t that be enough to dismiss the “Arod’s a choker myth?”
October 13th, 2009 at 2:53 pm
The sort of person who bought in to the “A-Rod is a choker” meme will never be talked out of it. Regurgitation of conventional wisdom and armchair psychology fill up a lot more column space than recognizing a sample size issue when you see it.
Someone pointed out elsewhere that Joe DiMaggio, True Yankee(tm), went 279/338/422 career postseason, with several notably poor series. While it was noticed in the press, it wasn’t a big deal. This sort of “analysis” really says a lot more about the writer than the subject.
October 13th, 2009 at 9:00 pm
Spike sed meme!
October 13th, 2009 at 10:36 pm
Sorry, Doc – people from my primary domain just don’t have very instinctive somas
October 18th, 2009 at 3:10 am
ALEX RODREGUEZ SHOULD STOP DOGGING HIS EXWIFE CYNTHIA! AND MAKING LIKE IT WAS ALL HER FAULT BEING MARRIED TO HER WAS THE REASON HE’S BEEN CHOKING, SHE WAS A GOOD WIFE & A GOOD MOTHER, HE SHOULD BE A REAL MAN & TELL THE MEDIA TO STOP MAKING COMPARISONS. A MILLION HOLLYWOOD KATE HUDSONS DONT EVER MAKE UP FOR THE CONTRIBUTION SHES MADE TO HIS CAREER..TAKING OWNERSHIP FINALLY OF HIS OWN PAST INDECRETIONS IS PERHAPS THE REAL REASON HIS HEAD IS FINALLY WHERE IT SHOULD BE.