The Value of Nick Swisher
By Mike Silva ~ October 2nd, 2009. Filed under: Mike Silva.
One of general manager Brian Cashman’s goals after last season’s terrible failure was to add players that have more grit, players willing to get their pinstripes dirty. It’s not just about talent; it’s about having a burning desire to win, yet knowing how to have fun. It takes more than talent to succeed in the postseason. – Kevin Kernan NY Post
That quote was part of a Kevin Kernan column which highlighted some of the hidden value of a Nick Swisher. Many believe he is one of the main reasons the Yankees clubhouse resembles a fraternity instead of the Pentagon. Swisher is the antithesis of Kevin Brown, Randy Johnson, and Gary Sheffield. The key with Swisher is that he also has produced at a high level on the field as well. His 29 homers, 82 RBI, and OPS of .870 is arguably his best professional season. Sure he plays the outfield like he is on roller skates, but if Lonnie Smith can play defense for a championship team than the Yankees shouldn’t have a problem with Swisher.
Many will laugh at the whole concept of “desire to win”, but I think fans who have watched this team all season would agree. I saw his enthusiasm that very first game in Baltimore when he started a Yankees comeback, albeit a failed one, but a comeback nonetheless. Need stats? Swisher’s 3.8 WAR, spotty defense and all, puts him ahead of David Wright, Jason Bay, and Justin Morneau. At 28 years old Swisher might be finally coming into his own. Considering the Yankees gave up Wilson Betemit and two minor leaguers you have to consider the deal a complete steal. He has a lot of Jason Giambi in him without the steroid induced decline.
The lack of attention Swisher seems to receive is amazing considering the solid combo of intangibles and production. Maybe it’s a product of being on a team with Jeter, Teixeira, and A-Rod. The Yankees lineup lacks a whole lot more depth without him. He also might become more important as the Yankees veterans continue to ascent north of age 35. In any event, I think it’s important to give Swisher his due.
