Mike Silva's New York Baseball Digest » Blog Archive » Would the Yanks Give Kids a Shot in 11′?

Would the Yanks Give Kids a Shot in 11′?



By Mike Silva ~ August 10th, 2010. Filed under: Mike Silva, Yanks Minors.

For as much as the fans love prospects it’s always a long shot they ever see the big leagues. That couldn’t be truer with the Yankees as it’s the worst place for a kid on the 40 man roster to be. You are stuck behind in prime stars and the organization is hesitant to take a chance on development because of the premium cost of going to a ballgame. The Yankees aren’t like anyone else in the sense that a “development year” needs to look like 2008 where they win 89 games and just miss the playoffs. When you think about it when was the last time that multiple youngsters have been incorporated into this team? During the first title year in 1996 Rivera, Pettitte, Bernie Williams, and Jeter were key contributors. A couple of years later Jorge Posada joined the mix. However, there hasn’t been a plethora of youngsters relied upon since that time, unless you count Phil Hughes and Joba Chamberlain who, by the nature of their bullpen roles, aren’t quite contributing at that same level.

You can’t completely blame the Yankees for this situation. Since Jeter and Bernie Williams there hasn’t been a ton of positional talent to incorporate into the team. Alfonso Soriano is the only one that comes to mind. However, there are few players are on the horizon and I wonder if they would give these kids a chance next year in the big leagues. Two that come to mind are Brandon Laird and Eduardo Nunez.

Laird continues his “breakout season” (as predicted by contributor Jed Weisberger in December). Since his Trenton promotion Laird has thumped AAA pitching to 1.047 OPS in six games. For the season he has 25 homers, 95 RBI and an OPS of .888. Playing the corners is a death sentence for this organization, but with A-Rod’s health in question there is a chance you could use Laird on the big league club. He could DH, give Teixeira and A-Rod a rest in the field, and provide a live bat off the bench. There is no rule that says he needs 600 AB’s his first year in the big leagues. Wouldn’t it be better to have Laird than Austin Kearns?

Eduardo Nunez is in an even more impossible situation. At 23 years old he is staring at another potential four years of Derek Jeter at shortstop. He won’t last with the organization till then, but the kid has a live bat and at the very least could be give them reason to upgrade from the light hitting Ramiro Pena. Even Jorge Vazquez, a Mexican League signing, could provide them more production than some of the veterans bats they currently employ.

Of course, the big name is Jesus Montero. Nearly a Mariner last month he is now squarely looking at a big league promotion in September. His slow start this year cast some doubt about his future, but is hitting well over .400 in August and might be a better DH option than Lance Berkman. I wonder if Montero holds his own in a big league stint they consider adding him to the postseason roster.

The best part about the farm system is how they could incorporate kids into the fifth starter role. While other teams search for a $5 million dollar a year veteran, the Yankees could possibly get well above replacement level production from a David Phelps or an Ivan Nova. This could continue for a few years as Hector Noesi, Manuel Banuelos, and Adam Warren are just a few that could follow.

Back in 2005 the Yankees made a conscience decision to focus on the farm system. Within five years their drafting, scouting, and planning has put them in the most enviable position. Yes, money had something to do with it, but they are full of smart baseball people who are given the autonomy to succeed in their roles. There is clear direction from the top down and everyone is on the same page. Now the key is having the courage to incorporate multiple young players into this mix. This could start as early as September with Montero, and possibly Laird, getting a call. Next year you could have three kids – Montero, Laird, and Nunez- who would be starting for most clubs.. Why not find a way to incorporate them into the club just like they have done with the pitchers? Unless there is a no doubt trade for a star on the horizon, it would be fun to see the next wave of great Yankee positional players get a shot. Right now they appear to be no worse than Nick Johnson, Austin Kearns, or Lance Berkman.

Mike Silva is a freelance writer and radio host since March of 2007. This website is his own personal "digest" of New York Baseball He's also hosts NYBD Radio on Blog Talk Radio and 1240 AM WGBB. Check out his sports media commentary at www.sportsmediawatchdog.com. Check out his official website, www.mikesilvamedia.com
Mike Silva
View all posts by Mike Silva
Mikes website

Post to Twitter Post to Yahoo Buzz Post to Delicious Post to Digg Post to Facebook

8 Responses to Would the Yanks Give Kids a Shot in 11′?

  1. Phil Privitera

    Mike,

    What about Cano and Gardner? I think if you are good enough the player will find a spot on the roster or get a starting job. I believe that has been Cashman’s plan for at least the last 2 years. Build up the farm system and sprinkle in the free agents where needed.

  2. Mike Silva

    That’s true

    I almost feel like Cano and Gardner were forced into action and the Yanks were fortunuate that it turned out well. Remember, they had Tony Womack as their 2b before Cano. I suspect Robbie was ready before his mid season callup in 2005.

    They have been doing that, but this is a bigger risk considering you might have to forgo a veteran free agent (see Nick Johnson this winter) and see what a kid has. Soriano was the last guy I remember where it seemed they were confident he was ready. Cano and Gardner I almost feel like they proved themselves with a short leash by having quick success.

    What if Laird or Montero are hitting .185 next April? Gotta give them some rope.

  3. Phil Privitera

    Alright now I’m going to throw some thoughts out there that for Yankee fans its almost sacreligious. It has crossed my mind that Cashman has almost considered Nunez untradeable. Is he considering asking Jeter to move to left field in a year or so. Yogi did it so why not Jeter.
    Laird is the player they are going to have to find a role for. Maybe he plays some in AAA next year but he will be ready in 2011.
    Montero and Cervelli will probably do the bulk of the catching in 2011 in Posada’s last year.
    Vazquez may find a spot on the bench next year.

  4. Viper

    Neither Laird or Montero are going to get big league call ups this season – at least not to play.

    Neither are on the 40 man roster and they won’t have to be until next season, especially Laird, since he has to be protected from the Rule 5 draft.

    I like Laird as much as the next guy but how is he better than Austin Kearns when he’s never faced major league pitching?

    Same for Montero over Berkman?

    You can’t make that assumption when one guy is an established player who has been around for a few years and the other has never had an AB in the bigs.

    People have to think like GMs – not fans.

  5. Paul Catalano

    I’d also throw David Robertson into the mix as a successful player from the minors.

    But yes, the Yankees should give their farm more of a chance, because really as you say, the journeymen they usually don’t seem to be paying off much better than say, a Nunez, Russo or Laird would.

  6. Mike Silva

    I don’t think I am thinking like a fan at all.

    First, there is still some guys on that are easily removable (Huffman, Golsen come to mind). Any GM would think like that as well. What more can Montero prove at AAA? Why not get a head start, at least, at seeing if he could hit MLB pitching

    As for the Laird vs. Kearns/Berkman – I meant that more towards next year, not this year.

  7. Mike Silva

    Phil

    I don’t see Jeter being able to play any other position competently at this point in his career. Also, his offense becomes very below average at any other position but SS

  8. Viper

    You’re not going to see either Montero or Laird playing in the Bronx in Sept.

    Cashman doesn’t need to promote either of them, especially not in the middle of a pennant race.

    They will both get their chances next season.

Leave a Reply