Mike Silva's New York Baseball Digest » Blog Archive » Five Points on the 2010 Yankees

Five Points on the 2010 Yankees



By Paul Catalano ~ December 3rd, 2009. Filed under: Digest Contributors, Offseason Speculation.

Now is the time of year when, undoubtedly, Yankee fans see thousands of articles on what to do in free agency, who to sign, etc. etc. Every nitpicky sports writer with an opinion tells the Yankee what to do. And to that I humbly add, my version.


1. Proceed with caution with Doc Halladay.

Let me just say this: Doc Halladay is worth a lot of the risks. Sure, he’s 32, threw a ton of innings, and would command a meaty and long paycheck. But if the Blue Jays demands are at least, somewhat reasonable, the Yanks should do it.

That said, don’t give up the farm. A package involving 2 or 3 of Austin Jackson, Phil Hughes, Jesus Montero and Joba Chamberlain….no. But trade 1 of them, and other prospects, then yes. (More on this later.)

As Mark Feinsand of the Daily News reports and Mike Silva echoed, it’s not just that Halladay would be a safe bet for 200 quality innings a season with a ton of Ks, It’s also that he would take so much pressure off the younger pitchers. He would eat up a lot of the innings they might otherwise be forced to face, and would serve as a mentor for them. AJ Burnett credits Halladay as a huge influence in his maturation while the both of them were in Toronto. So again, proceed with caution in getting Halladay, but definitely go after him hard.

2. Move Posada to DH on a semi-regular basis
We already know that Jorge will be DH-ing whenever Burnett is on the mound. But even so, he should probably do it more often.

There were signs, especially later in the season, that Posada was wearing down behind the plate. Despite only catching 100 games all season, Posada had 7 errors and tied a career low for fielding percentage. He also tied his career low in base runners caught stealing percentage. And lastly, in his entire career, 2009 was the worst year for pitchers pitching to Posada: Yankee pitchers had a 5.02 ERA when pitching to Posada—the overall team ERA was 4.28

It’s time to phase Posada to DH, even more so than last year. The Yankees should resign Jose Molina, an outstanding defensive catcher, though a liability at the plate, and see what Francisco Cervelli can do with more regular playing time. Posada can still bring it with the stick, hitting 22 HRs and batting .285 with a .522 slugging percentage, so he should definitely be manning his middle-of-the-lineup spot, just not so much with the catching every day. While it is too early for the Yankees blue-chip catching prospects, Austin Romaine and Jesus Montero to get true consideration as 2010 options, it isn’t too early to begin the phase-out of Posada from behind the plate.

3. Get the outfield in order.
I, for one, am not a big proponent for going after Matt Holliday or Jason Bay. Not that they wouldn’t look nice in pinstripes, but the money the Yankees would spend might be used better elsewhere. In short, they aren’t really big needs for the Yankees. And they have perfectly good parts right here.

Damon might get the big 4-year contract he is looking for, but it probably won’t be with the Yankees. It isn’t a strong free agent class for outfielders, once you get past Jason Bay and Matt Holliday, so somebody might take a chance on Damon (And as reports indicate that someone might be the cross-town Mets). But if not, resigning Damon to a two-year deal and letting him ease Jackson, Gardner, and some of the youngsters into everyday outfield spots would not be the worst idea.

In Damon’s 4-year Yankee career, he has put up solid numbers and has averaged about 145 games a year. Not bad at all. If he could be resigned to match those numbers for two more year, great. If not, look into other options.

As for Swisher, I’m not as aggressive on trading him as some other are. He’s signed to a reasonable contract through 2011, and while he will never hit for a high batting average, he does draw walks, is a switch-hitter and has power. His ideal position, it would seem to me, is as an off the bench, 4th outfield/1st baseman/pinch hitter. To me, Swisher doesn’t have the chops to be an everyday player. As 2009 showed, he gets into some serious funks throughout the year—he batted .150 for the month of May, and .158 over the 28 days of the season. With Austin Jackson, Brett Gardner and Melky Cabrera (maybe Jesus Montero in 2011 being slid into RF) and possibly Johnny Damon vying for spots in the Yankee 2010 outfield, a big-ticket free agent isn’t required.

4. Find out what’s going on with the young pitchers
Once and for all find out if Hughes and Chamberlain are starters or relievers. While I’m a proponent of trying to shape Chamberlain into a Beckett-Clemens type starter, if he is more comfortable in the pen, then having a successor to Rivera would not be the worst thing in the world. But make sure you figure this out in February, not June.

As for Hughes, I truly believe, in the long term, he will be a plus starter. In 2010, he will probably have a Joba-type pitch count, much to the consternation of the Yankee fans and beat writers. All that is fine by me, but if he does have a pitch count, don’t switch him from the pen to a starter and back again. Train him to be a starter and let him work through any problems he may have.

Also, find out what you have with Ian Kennedy, Zach McAllister, Mark Melancon and Mike Dunn. Can they be viable parts of the puzzle in 2010, as Phil Coke and David Robertson were in 2009? Or would they maybe be more helpful as pieces in a Halladay trade.

5. The Big One—middle infield
OK, first Cano.
By all accounts, Cano had an exceptional bounce back year. He batted .320 and played a much-improved 2nd base. That said, in the postseason, Cano laid a Brontosaurus-sized egg, going 11 for 57 with no home runs. Once upon a time, the Yankees traded Alfonso Soriano for performing similarly in the postseason. And there are some grumblings about trading Cano for a quality arm or prospects in return.

Cano should not be traded. He is 26 and still has room to grow, so any trade would have to be a bonanza type trade foe the Yankees. On the other hand, perhaps quietly, Cashman could look around and see what could be had for him. Kevin Russo has been playing very well at 2B in AAA—perhaps a Cano, McAllister, plus others package could get you Halladay?

Now Jeter. Here’s the gargantuan elephant in the room. How long do you realistically go with an aging Jeter at shortstop? Yes, he played an improved shortstop this year, but he turns 36 next year, and with first base locked up for the long-term future, what do we do with Jeter when we resign him? Can he be a quality outfield? What would his range be out there? A thought: if Cano gets traded, could Jeter be placed at 2B and be somewhat protected by Teixeira? Then who plays shortstop in 2011? No prospect on the farm is ready to take over at short. The Yankees need to address this issue and soon.

The Yankees are in a good position. Yes, there are concerns to address, but nothing is huge and untenable. If the Yankees are smart and judicious, they can enter 2010 with a better foundation, better pitching, younger and more cost-effective. Here’s looking forward that the do just that.

Post to Twitter Post to Yahoo Buzz Post to Delicious Post to Digg Post to Facebook

The following two tabs change content below.
Paul Catalano is an aspiring sportswriter who’s day job is as Production Manager for Field & Stream, Outdoor Life & Shot Business magazines. He has written often for his own blog at And a Player to be Named Later since 2007. His articles have been picked up by Dugout Central, Foxsports.com, Lindys.com among others. Before that, Paul got married to the lovely Elizabeth Ryan, got his Master’s in Writing from Emerson College, attended his first Yankee game at 9 years old, got his first base hit at 5 years old and was born.

2 Responses to Five Points on the 2010 Yankees

  1. Steve G

    Excellent article… agree with you on just about every point. I was under the impression it wouldn’t take as much as Cano to get Doc. I would also quietly shop Cano to see what’s possible.

    I know this has been mentioned in the past, but we all know how Torre loves Cano. At the same time we’ve been hearing about Austin Jackson for about 3 years, and his numbers don’t impress me in the minors at all. Is it possible to put Jackson in left, either at the end of this year, or for 2011, and sign Matt Kemp. This guy would be a perfect young player with speed and the aggressive play that Cano lacks. He could slide into that 2 hole wonderfully. Hudson’s gone, who’s playing second for the Dodgers.

    I know this is extremely unlikely and I sound like every other Yankee fan who wants everything, but that one for one trade could help both teams.

  2. Chris Silva

    Not far fetched at all Steve. There was some talk before 2008 of a Cano for Kemp swap. It’s a very fair deal that would help both teams. Not sure who the Dodgers have in their system to play CF. But, a very interesting idea and wouldn’t be surprised if you see Cano shopped. The way I look at it, you’ve gotton the best production out of him that you’ll probably ever get. Also, Cano has a bit of a reputation for being a bit lazy (see 2008 season).

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.